The Trial of the Killers and Its Aftermath

Tallahatchie County CourthouseIt was only three weeks after Emmett Till was abducted that his accused killers were placed on trial in Mississippi. Tillís abduction and slaying had already made international headlines, and they continued throughout the week in September, when Roy Bryant and J. W. Milam sat accused of murder in a crowded courtroom. 

Mississippi Governor Hugh White called for a special prosecutor to try the case, and this was found in District Attorney Gerald Chatham. All five of Sumnerís attorneys worked pro bono in defense of the accused. Circuit judge Curtis Swango presided.  Over seventy reporters and photographers, black and white, descended upon the tiny Delta town. For the first time. Southern racism was not only a national story, but an international one.

By way of introduction, the trial, by its participants, may be summarized as follows:

                                         

State of Mississippi vs J. W. Milam and Roy Bryant

Held in Sumner, Tallahatchie County, Mississippi

September 19-23, 1955

 

Presiding:

Judge Curtis M. Swango

 

Prosecution Team:

Gerald Chatham

Robert B. Smith, III

James Hamilton Caldwell, Jr.

 

Defense Team:

Jesse Josiah Breland

C. Sidney Carlton

Robert Harvey Henderson

Joseph W. Kellum

John W. Whitten

 

Prosecution Witnesses:

Mary Amanda Bradley, Mamie Till Bradley, John Ed Cothran,

Robert Hodges, Chester Miller, Benjamin L. Mims, Charles Nelson,

Add Reed, Willie Reed, George Smith,

C. A. Strickland, Moses Wright

 

Defense Witnesses:

Lee Russell Allison, L. W. Boyce, Carolyn Bryant,

Grover Duke, Pete McGaa, Harry D. Malone,

Juanita Milam, Luther B. Otkens, Harold Perry,

James Sanders, Franklin Smith, Henry Clarence Strider

 

Jurors:

Howard Armstrong, Ed Devaney, George Holland,

Bishop Matthews, Davis Newton, Jim Pennington,

Lee L. Price, Gus Ramsey, James Shaw, Jr.,

Travis Thomas, James Toole, Ray Tribble

Alternate:

Willie D. Haven

 

Day One: September 19, 1955

 

Day Two: September 20, 1955

 

Day Three: September 21, 1955

 

Day Four: September 22, 1955

 

Day Five: September 23, 1955

           

Continue to the next section

Emmett Till